
The trademark proprietor’s right to prohibit use of its trademark and acquiescence – the Dracula case (KKO:2026:30)
Insights|November 4, 2026
The Supreme Court of Finland has clarified the legal basis for acquiescence in Finnish trademark law, potentially changing how matters involving trademark proprietors’ inaction in respect of third party marks are handled from now on. As a result, the registration of one’s own trademarks may have greater significance.
Facts and background
The case concerned the relationship between the rights of the trademark proprietor to prohibit use of its trademark and its passivity in respect of marks that had been used by another company on the market for a long time.
Since the 1980s, Karkkimies Oy-Candyman Ltd and its predecessors have imported and marketed sweets bearing the Dracula marks in Finland. In 2019, Hardeco Finland Oy (Hardeco) acquired the business of Karkkimies Oy-Candyman Ltd and continued its predecessor’s operations. The Dracula marks used by these operators were not registered.
In 2003, Lunapark Scandinavia Oy Ltd (Lunapark) applied for the Dracula trademark in Finland in Class 30, which includes confectionery, and was granted registration in 2009. Even before the trademark application, Lunapark and Hardeco and its predecessors operated in the same field of business and provided confectionery with the same or similar Dracula marks. The parties used the marks side by side also after the registration.
Lunapark has been aware of the products of Hardeco and its predecessors and their use of the mark for decades but did not take any action against this use prior to 2020. In 2020, Lunapark brought an action against Hardeco, demanding that it ceases using the Dracula marks and pay compensation for the infringement.
The matter has been reviewed by the Market Court and Supreme Court of Finland. The Supreme Court has also requested a preliminary ruling from the Court of Justice of the European Union. The main question in the dispute related to the decades of co-existence of the parties’ marks and the possible loss of right to enforce trademark rights owned by Lunapark.
Market Court
According to the Market Court, Lunapark’s registered trademark and the marks used by Hardeco and its predecessors over the decades were either identical or similar. Therefore, in principle, Lunapark would have had the right to prohibit Hardeco’s use of these marks. Hardeco did not succeed in proving established trademark rights in the mark Dracula.
The marks of Lunapark as well as of Hardeco and its predecessors had been in use side by side for a long time, and Lunapark did not object to the other party’s use of its mark.
According to the section 15 of the Finnish Trademark Act, if the owner of the earlier trademark has not intervened in the use of a later registered or established trademark acquired in good faith, the right to intervene is lost after five years of becoming aware of such use. There is no specific provision in the Finnish Trademark Act to assess whether the long-term use of an unprotected mark could result in the proprietor of a registered trademark could lose the right to object to the use of that mark due to their inaction.
According to a general principle of private law in Finland, an action must be brought before a court within a reasonable time from when the claimant became, or ought to have become, aware of the facts forming the basis of the claim.
As Hardeco did not have registered or established trademarks in respect of mark Dracula, passivity based on the Finnish Trademark Act could not apply. The Market Court based its decision on the general principle of private law of Finland. As the concurrent use had continued for a long time and even after registration of the trademark of Lunapark, the Market Court found that Lunapark had, due to its inaction, lost the right to bring claims against Hardeco based on the infringement and dismissed the claims. The fact that Karkkimies Oy-Candyman Ltd had been replaced by Hardeco had no legal significance.
The Supreme Court and the CJEU
The case proceeded to the Supreme Court, which ruled on whether Lunapark had lost its right to bring a claim due to inactivity based on the general principle of private law of Finland.
The Supreme Court has requested a preliminary ruling from the Court of Justice of the European Union, asking the following:
“Does Article 10 of [Directive 2015/2436] preclude the application, in a dispute concerning a trade mark infringement, of a national principle whereby the proprietor of a trade mark, also in cases other than those covered by Article 18(1) and Article 9(1) or (2) of [that directive], could forfeit the right conferred on him or her by Article 10(2) and (3) [thereof] to prohibit a third party from using a sign the use of which adversely affects or is liable adversely to affect one of the functions of the trade mark, on the ground that, though being aware of the use of the mark, he or she has not applied for prohibition of that use within a reasonable time?”
The response was positive and thus, a general principle of private law of Finland could not restrict a trademark proprietor’s right to prohibit unauthorized use of its trademark.
According to the Court of Justice, Article 10 of the Trade Mark Directive fully harmonises the rights of the trademark proprietor, while Article 18(1) fully harmonises the conditions under which those rights may be limited due to passivity of the proprietor. The rights of a trademark proprietor may be restricted only as indicated in the Directive, and any other interpretation would undermine uniform practice within the European Union. In the above mentioned Articles, there is no mention of the loss of trademark proprietor’s right to prohibit unauthorized use of its trademark based on a national principle of private law.
Since Hardeco did not have registered trademark rights or established trademark rights in the mark Dracula, the criteria regarding passivity of Section 15 of the Finnish Trademark Act were not met. As private law principles did not apply either, Lunapark did not lose its right to prohibit use as a result of its inaction in this matter, and the Supreme Court upheld Lunapark’s claims and overturned the Market Court’s decision. Hardeco was therefore found to have infringed Lunapark’s trademark and was prohibited, on pain of a fine of EUR 50 000 from continuing or repeating the use of Lunapark’s mark or similar. With regard to Lunapark’s claim for compensation, the case was referred back to the Market Court.
Considerations
A key takeaway from the case is that in Finland, from now on, passivity may only be based on Section 15 of the Finnish Trademark Act, meaning that the trademark owner may lose the right to prohibit the use of another mark only on the basis of a subsequently registered or established mark, provided that the mark is applied or used in good faith.
It would be recommendable to register all new marks and, now, even marks that have been in use without registration to secure one’s rights and in order to be able to rely on potential passivity in the future. Registration is the easiest way to secure one’s own rights in the trademark. Even though the mark can be established after substantial use without registration, it may be necessary to provide a considerable amount of evidence in court to prove that an established trademark right exists. This requires substantial resources, and the result is not always certain.
Read more about the case on the Supreme Court’s website (in Finnish)